10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (2024)

As you may or may not know, there are tons of pawn shops out there in the Columbus Ohio area. However, not all these pawn shops are the same and can provide you with the best value for your valuables. Also, not all these pawnbrokers can provide you with products and services worth all the time, effort, and money spent.

Join Our Facebook Group

Introducing our new group for Buying and Selling liquidation goods and merchandise!

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (1)

Group Link: https://www.facebook.com/groups/937259116458055/

Find exclusive deals and merchandise opportunities!

To make it easy for you, we have put together the best pawnbrokers or pawn shops that are absolutely worth it and you can visit. All the listed pawn shops are reputed, trustworthy, and have amazing customer ratings & ratings.

You can go with any one of them that best fits your budget, needs, and other preferences. You can go with any of the listed options without any second thoughts or worrying much. We are pretty sure that you won’t be disappointed.

Best Pawn Shops in Columbus Ohio:

Buckeye Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (2)

Let’s start with one of our personal favorites on the list, Buckeye Pawn Shop. Whenever it comes to the best pawn shops in Columbus Ohio, the name Buckeye strikes the mind first. Well, there are many reasons why you can consider Buckeye to be your number-one preference for pawn shops. Let’s have a look at a few of them.

To begin with, Buckeye Pawn Shop has been in business since 1989. Since then, the shop has been helping the people of the area get the best cash value for all their valuables. The shop, to date, has always been known for keeping the satisfaction of its customers the number one priority. Hence, all these make it one of the pioneer pawn shops in the area on which you can rely without any second thoughts or worrying about anything.

At Buckeye Pawn Shop, you get a wide range of options to choose from to pawn and to buy. Items that you can choose from include jewelry, tools, firearms, electronics, sporting goods, musical instruments, lawn equipment, and many more such items of value.

Whereas, if we take a look into the services offered by Buckeye Pawn Shop, even then there’s quite a number of them. The range of services offered here includes loans (pawning), purchases, layaway, expert jewelry repair, and broken gold purchase.

Last but not least, Buckeye Pawn Shop is located in four different locations in Columbus Ohio. So, you can choose to visit any one of whichever suits your distance, needs, and other preferences.

Buckeye’s pawn shops are located on Harrisburg Pike, S. High Street, S. Central Avenue, and N. Walnut Street. The timings of the shops are from 9:00 am to 5:30 pm Monday to Friday and from 10:00 am to 2:00 pm Sunday.

Address: 1801 Harrisburg Pike, Columbus, OH 43223, United States

Phone: +1 614-276-7500

Get Directions

Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (3)

After Buckeye, the next name that strikes the mind when thinking of the best Columbus pawn shops is Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn. It is one of Columbus Ohio’s premium and leading pawn shops. So, if you wish to get get the best cash value for all your valuables, then you should straight head to this place.

Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn has been successfully running the business for the past 30 years. It first started in the year 1988 primarily as a coin, paper money, precious metals, and jewelry retailer and wholesaler. Later, seeing the demand and amazing response from customers, in 2012, it turned into a pawnbroker.

You can rely on Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn to pawn your valuables, buy valuable items, or get cash loans with fair interest rates. To add a cherry to the cake, Gemco Jewelry & Coins deals in a wide array of items.

So, you can pawn or buy all forms of valuables that you might have and think of here. Well, some of the popular items include jewelry, gold coins, old gold, silver, toys, watches, guns, ammunition, antiques, electronics, musical instruments, and many more collectibles.

You can definitely consider once visiting Gemco’s pawn shop located at 5311 W Broad St, Columbus Ohio. You can visit Gemco’s pawn shop any day from Monday to Saturday between 9:30 am to 5:30 pm.

Address: 5311 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228, United States

Phone: +1 614-878-2646

Get Directions

Lev’s Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (4)

If you live in Columbus Ohio or nearby and have been looking for the best pawn shops for a while, you must know about Lev’s Pawn Shop. There’s a high probability that you must have heard or come across the name Lev’s Pawn Shop. Well, we say so because Lev’s Pawn Shop, in today’s date, is one of the fastest growing chains of pawn shops Columbus Ohio.

Well, Lev’s Pawn Shop was first started in the year 1980 by Lev and Lidia Kucherski. They started with the shop on East Main Street and gradually, over the years, expanded to Indiana, Florida, and many more locations. This has only been possible as they have been serving people with top-notch cheap products as well as service.

At Lev’s Pawn Shop, there are always find well-trained and experienced professionals always ready to help with all your needs. Hence, all this has led to Lev’s Pawn Shop being considered one of the most trusted, reputed, and reliable pawn shops in the area.

You can rely on Lev’s Pawn Shop to get the best cash value for all your collectibles, vehicles, jewelry, firearms, tools, electronics, and more. Not just this, you can also rely on Lev’s Pawn Shop to buy a wide variety of items including jewelry, firearms, tools, electronics, and a lot more.

The best part is that if you wish to buy from the shop, one thing is assured you’ll get the best deals possible on all those items.

Address: 3446 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, United States

Phone: +1 614-231-1688

Get Directions

Related:- Best Pawn Shops in Lexington

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (5)

The next entry on this list of best pawn shops in Columbus Ohio is Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry. You must be wondering why it’s the next entry as we have already discussed Buckeye in our previous entries.

Well, previously, we discussed Buckeye Pawn Shop which dealt with a wide range of merchandise. However, in this case, Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry only deals in gold, silver, platinum, jewelry, diamonds, coins, and other such precious items.

So, if your needs are related to any of such precious items, then there’s hardly any better place out there that you can visit. Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry has got multiple shops conveniently located in neighborhoods throughout Columbus and Central Ohio.

Address: 5831 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH 43017, United States

Phone: +1 614-793-4653

Get Directions

Mike’s Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (6)

If you are looking for a place specializing exclusively in high-end jewelry and watches such as Rolex, Cartier, Breitling, etc., then Mike’s Pawn Shops is the best option for you. Well, not just high-end jewelry and watches, Mike’s Pawn Shop is also the best option if you’re looking for firearms and other accessories. You can visit this Columbus pawn shop to buy, sell, trade, or loan all this variety of items.

Mike’s Pawn Shop is a family-owned and operated business in Columbus Ohio. It has been in the business for more than 30 years and serves people with quality products and services. Mike’s Pawn Shop, over the years, they have built quite a good reputation in the market. They are well known for their quality products as well as fast, professional, and friendly services.

Mike’s Pawn Shops is conveniently located on the corner of Cooke Rd and Cleveland Avenue. To be more precise, the shop is located at 3745 Cleveland Avenue, Columbus, Ohio. The shop is just next to Vance’s Gun Store along with plenty of parking space.

You can visit the shop any day from Monday to Friday between 10:00 am to 5:00 pm. Apart from the weekdays, you can also visit the shop on Saturdays between 10:00 am to 3:00 pm.

Address: 3745 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224, United States

Phone: +1 614-475-5590

Get Directions

E Z Cash Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (7)

If you are looking for a pawn shop in Columbus Ohio that will give you the best loan at cheap interest rates, your search ends here. E Z Cash Pawn Shop is the right choice for you as here, you’ll get the value for all the items you bring and pawn.

E Z Cash Pawn Shop claims to pay its customers the most for their valuables than any other pawn shop out there in the area. After doing research on our part and going through what the customers have to say, we must say that E Z Cash Pawn Shop pays the most than most shops around.

E Z Cash Pawn Shop was founded in the year 1992. For the past 25 years, they have been proudly serving the people of Central Ohio with quality products and services. At E Z Cash Pawn Shop, you can go for buying or selling valuables, especially gold and jewelry.

Well, the services here are not just get limited to buying or selling valuables like gold and jewelry. But, services provided also include pawn loans, jewelry repair, and buying & selling of other merchandise.

E-Z Cash’s Pawn Shop is located in four different locations in Columbus Ohio. These Columbus pawn shops are located on East Main Street, Morse Road, West Broad Street, and Livingstone Avenue.

Address: 3659 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228, United States

Phone: +1 614-272-2700

Get Directions

Luigi’s Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (8)

Next up, on this list of best pawn shops in Columbus Ohio, we have Luigi’s Pawn Shop. Luigi’s Pawn Shop is another great option you can consider in Columbus Ohio to buy, sell, and pawn a variety of merchandise.

The variety of merchandise that the pawn shop deals in includes jewelry, electronics, musical merchandise, camera equipment, gaming systems, bikes, tools, and more.

You can visit Luigi’s Pawn Shop located at 1245 North High Street, Columbus, Ohio. You can visit the pawn shop any day from Monday to Saturday anytime between 10:00 am to 5:00 pm.

Address: 1245 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States

Phone: +1 614-294-2130

Get Directions

Big Bucks Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (9)

If you are looking for a quick cash loan or simply want to sell/pawn/buy/trade merchandise, the Big Bucks Pawn Shop is the place you should straight head to. Big Bucks pawn Shop deals in a variety of merchandise including firearms, jewelry, gold, electronics, tools, gadgets, vehicles, sporting goods, etc.

Big Bucks Pawn Shop is way better than other options out there as they make sure that customers are fully satisfied with the products and services provided as well as get the best value and deals.

Address: 6065 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43232, United States

Phone: +1 614-864-2500

Get Directions

Buy Here Sell Here

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (10)

Buy Here Sell Here, as the name suggests, is a place where you can buy or sell a wide range of merchandise. You can rely on Buy Here Sell Here to convert your jewelry, broken gold, electronics, computers, and tools into instant cash.

If you are looking for buying and selling firearms in Columbus Ohio, then Buy Here Sell here is one of the best options you can go for. Well, this is because unlike most other places out there, they are a licensed firearms dealer.

They deal in high-end firearms including handguns, shotguns, rifles, etc. Buy Here Sell Here provide full pawnbroker services at two convenient locations, called the East Store and West Store.

Address: 1257 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222, United States

Phone: +1 614-235-6400

Get Directions

Dash 2 Cash Pawn Shop

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (11)

The last entry that we have on this list is Dash 2 Cash Pawn Shop. Just by considering it as the last entry on the list, don’t take the shop lightly.

Dash 2 Cash Pawn Shop is an American, Army Veteran owned pawn shop that has been serving the greater Columbus, Ohio area for many years. It has been serving the people in the greater Columbus, Ohio area since 2014.

The merchandise that Dash 2 Cash Pawn Shop deals in includes jewelry, firearms, electronics, tools, musical instruments, and many more.

Address: 1253 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43229, United States

Phone: +1 614-817-1190

Get Directions


So, with all these said, we come to the end of this list of “Best Pawn shops in Columbus Ohio”. These were our top 10 picks for pawn shops in the area that you can visit this year. Last but not least, make sure you save this post and share it with others looking for Columbus pawn shops.

Also, let us know in case there’re any queries, doubts, suggestions, etc. related to the topic through the comments below.

10 Best & Historical Pawn Shops in Columbus, Ohio (2024) (2024)


What is the most successful pawn shop? ›

Biggest companies in the Pawn Shops industry in the US
CompanyRevenue ($m) 2023Profit Margin (%) 2023
First Cash Corp1,027.29.8
Ezcorp, Inc.766.48.2

What pawn shops want the most? ›

  • Jewelry. Necklaces, Bracelets, Rings, Watches, Earrings, Pins, Gold Jewelry, Silver Jewelry. ...
  • Precious Metals. Gold, Silver, Platinum, Copper. ...
  • Gemstones. Gemstones are also a great way to get quick cash. ...
  • Electronics. ...
  • Firearms (registered to you) ...
  • Power Tools + Equipment. ...
  • Antiques / Collectibles. ...
  • Musical Instruments.

How to haggle pawn shops? ›

Don't Be Afraid to Haggle

Haggling is a common practice when it comes to pawn shops, so don't be afraid to negotiate. Start by making an offer that's slightly higher than what you're willing to accept, and be prepared to meet somewhere in the middle.

How do I find the right pawn shop? ›

To help you make an informed decision, here are seven tips to help you find the best pawn shop.
  1. Ask for Recommendations. ...
  2. Look at Their Reputation. ...
  3. Check Customer Reviews. ...
  4. Consider Their Fairness and Expertise. ...
  5. Ensure They're Licensed. ...
  6. Check the Quality of Their Customer Service. ...
  7. Consider Your Needs.
Feb 3, 2023

Where do Pawn Stars sell their items? ›

The series is filmed on location at the World-Famous Gold & Silver Pawn Shop in Las Vegas, Nevada.

What is the biggest Pawn Stars sale? ›

1. Maurice Sendak Sketches. Price Deal: $250,000 In the episode "Can't Pawn Me Love" from Season 15, Rick Harrison acquired original Maurice Sendak sketches for Where the Wild Things Are. These unique sketches, never sold as reproductions, were estimated by an art expert to be worth $310,000.

What is better than a pawn shop? ›

You are most likely to get the best value for the item you want to exchange at a buy-sell-trade store — rather than accepting a high-rate loan that doesn't match your item in value, you'll receive a fair and honest amount of money or the equivalent value in store credit.

What items will pawn shops not buy? ›

5 Things Not to Sell to a Pawn Shop
  • Illegal Goods. You'd be surprised how many criminals try to take their stolen or illegal goods into a pawn shop and exchange them for cash. ...
  • VCRs and VHS Tapes. ...
  • Old Mattresses. ...
  • Old Cellphones. ...
  • Cassette Players.

What sells for $100 at a pawn shop? ›

What Can You Pawn for $100?
  • Snowboard.
  • Flat-screen TV.
  • Tablet.
  • Bose speakers.
  • Apple watch.
  • Refrigerator.
  • GoPro.
  • Power tools.
Mar 26, 2024

What percentage should you expect from a pawn shop? ›

At a pawn shop, you leave your property and, in return, the pawnbroker typically lends you approximately 25% to 60% of the item's resale value. The most commonly pawned items are jewelry, electronic and photography equipment, musical instruments, and firearms. The average amount of a pawn shop loan is about $75–$100.

What do pawn shops value the most? ›

What Are Things Pawn Shops Always Buy? Pawn shops always buy precious metals like gold and silver, and most of them also buy jewlery and watches. Generally, anything that sells very quickly and is popular with collectors is something a pawn shop should buy from you.

How much will a pawn shop come down on price? ›

Most pawn shops do negotiate for sales – but don't expect to get more than 60% of the value of your item. Remember – their end goal is to resell your item for a profit. They don't care about the sentimental value or history, or even the unique details that add value.

What should I turn my pawn into? ›

Most of the time, players promote a pawn to a queen, which is popularly known as "queening the pawn." After one player promotes a pawn, the other player has to move (unless they are checkmated, of course).

How do you catch a pawn? ›

A pawn captures by moving diagonally forward one square to the left or right (see diagram), either replacing an enemy piece on its square or capturing en passant. An en passant capture can occur after a pawn makes a move of two squares and the square it passes over is attacked by an enemy pawn.

Which pawn should I move first? ›

1) Good chess strategy is to make your first move with the e-pawn or d-pawn advancing two squares. In either case, you will open pathways for the pieces to get off of the back rank and into the fight for the central squares.

What is the largest pawn shop in the world? ›

Gold & Silver Pawn Shop.

Does Rick still work at the pawn shop? ›

Rick is not a full-time employee at the Pawn Shop anymore. He currently stars in Pawn Stars Do America season 2 which shows Rick, Corey, and iconic Austin “Chumlee” Russell hitting the road to visit eight different cities in search of historical finds.

What was the best profit from Pawn Stars? ›

We count down the 10 biggest payouts ever on the history of the show.
  • $80k - 1922 Proof Peace High Relief Dollar. ...
  • $68,250 - 1932 Custom Ford Roadster. ...
  • $67.5k - 1915 Panama Pacific Octagonal Gold Coin. ...
  • $60k - 2014 Hertz Penske GT Mustang. ...
  • $60k - JFK Cigar Box. ...
  • $55k - Vic Flicks 1961 Fender Stratocaster Guitar.


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Last Updated:

Views: 5648

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Birthday: 2001-01-17

Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

Phone: +813077629322

Job: Real-Estate Executive

Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.